Go for 1 or 2?
From the 3, 47% of 1-point tries got in. From the 10, 38% of 2-point tries did. The longer try is barely harder, and it's worth twice as much.
The 2-point try starts 7 yards farther back. It got in about 9 fewer times out of every 100.
more points per touchdown by going for 2, once you count what each try is worth.
of tries were 2-point tries. Teams went for 1 the rest of the time.
states cleared the line. Every state with enough games, shown below.
Going for 2 won in every state.
In every state, 2-point tries got in more than half as often as 1-point tries. That's the line where going for 2 pays off.
It isn't just the good teams.
Coaches choose when to go for 2, so we checked whether strong teams were behind the numbers. Every group cleared the line.
The same team, both ways
36 of 47 teams that tried plenty of both cleared the line on their own.
Teams with winning records
91 teams. The line to beat was 25%.
Teams with losing records
70 teams. The line to beat was 21%.
If you go for 1, run it.
From the 3, runs got in 55% of the time and passes 45%. A pass can also be picked off and returned for 2 points. Still, more than three in four 1-point tries were passes.
Even a 55% run from the 3 sets the line at 27%, and both kinds of 2-point try clear it.
Try it with your team.
Set how often your 1-point try works. That sets the line your 2-point try has to beat.
This compares points only. It leaves out the score late in a game and the rare intercepted try.